|
Apologetic discussions Apologetic Discussions Regarding the Teachings of Watchman Nee and Witness Lee |
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
08-23-2012, 09:55 PM | #1 |
I Have Finished My Course
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Avon, OH
Posts: 303
|
Organic Salvation
Organic Salvation
This teaching is something I learned in the local churches and from reading Witness Lee – and it is a cornerstone of my faith. I agree there is a danger in mechanizing this concept into a simple “eat Christ” through defined practices like calling on the Lord, pray-reading and prophesying from the HWMR. But when this concept of “organic salvation” is tied to the Biblical truth of God’s “multifarious wisdom” and “varied grace” – then its limitless how God can operate in one’s life. The alternative to “organic salvation” is WWJD (what would Jesus do) – salvation by imitation. (I talk disparaginingly, but there is also a value in WWJD which James talked extensively about - but evidence of "works" seems to me to more of a "barometer" of one's health, not a prescription to "just do it."). Thing is, when it comes to my greatest internal failings, I don’t know how to “pull myself up by my bootstraps” to be a “good Christian.” Seeing a positive model, like Jesus, and “imitating” is a recipe for self-loathing. Because I fail time and again when I attempt it (which is not to say I stop attempting). There is a hope in “organic salvation.” But-for that hope, I wouldn’t even know how to think about the wretched man that I am. Paul’s angst in Romans 7 is palpable for me. That there is a Savior who not only overcame sin judicially, but actually indwells me – One who can be touched by the feeling of my weakness, and still overcame – that breeds hope. Despite having paroused numerous Christian environments since I stopped meeting with the LC, no one has invoked this hope as poignantly as I learned it in the LC. This fundamental faith in the Spirit which indwells me – albeit in humility (which I picked up after the LC) – is actually the very thing that has enabled a critique of the LC’s more abusive doctrines and practices. But I did learn it there. And it was a central teaching from Witness Lee. Even as I rely on it to criticize the LC, I would be remiss if I neglected to emphasize that I initially learned it there. Thoughts? In Love, Peter
__________________
I Have Finished My Course |
08-24-2012, 06:01 AM | #2 | |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: USA
Posts: 4,333
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
It's too deep for me. I can't even understand why a bike doesn't fall over when it's moving forward. But I know that's what happens. Faith is like that. When it's in action it flows. When we try to analyze it it doesn't quite make sense. Everything cannot be explained because if it could we would begin to worship the explanation and not the source. Christ is the only true image of God, the only begotten Son. Any other image of God, including our explanations of him, must by necessity be imperfect and incomplete. If they weren't we would have to worship them as we do the Son. As to actually having learned something worthwhile in the LRC, who is to say you wouldn't have learned it somewhere else as well? Many people understand the "organic" aspect of salvation without using that term. Actually, I don't like the term "organic" because it seems impersonal and clinical and just a tad pretentious. Why not just say "life relationship?" Organic makes me think of organic compost, or a biology experiment. |
|
08-24-2012, 07:20 AM | #3 | |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Greater Ohio
Posts: 13,693
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
If only faith were as easy as riding a bike.
__________________
Ohio's motto is: With God all things are possible!. Keeping all my posts short, quick, living, and to the point! |
|
08-24-2012, 08:39 AM | #4 | |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Natal Transvaal
Posts: 5,631
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
My journey includes some time in the LRC (Lord's Recovery Church) so my ideas are colored by that experience. What I learned, saw, thought, read, spoke. But to compare it with someone else's journey, which may or may not include the word "organic" in some fashion, is to me irrelevant. Jesus said, "What is that to you? You follow Me".
__________________
"Freedom is free. It's slavery that's so horribly expensive" - Colonel Templeton, ret., of the 12th Scottish Highlanders, the 'Black Fusiliers' |
|
08-24-2012, 08:53 AM | #5 | |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: USA
Posts: 4,333
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
I don't doubt Peter's sincerity. But the LC has a pattern of special language. And too much special language can lead one to believe one has special experiences, as we've seen. |
|
08-24-2012, 09:04 AM | #6 |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Natal Transvaal
Posts: 5,631
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Language is merely an approximation of experience, as we try to convey it to ourselves and each other. When it becomes special, i.e. too restrictive or insular in meaning, it can become a trap. We can get stuck in yesterday's experience, and the journey ends. We don't hold the language; it holds us. Jesus destroyed the special language of the scribes and the pharisees (i.e. "We have Moses"), and I daresay He'd make short work of the "high peak truths".
__________________
"Freedom is free. It's slavery that's so horribly expensive" - Colonel Templeton, ret., of the 12th Scottish Highlanders, the 'Black Fusiliers' |
08-24-2012, 09:09 AM | #7 | |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Greater Ohio
Posts: 13,693
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
__________________
Ohio's motto is: With God all things are possible!. Keeping all my posts short, quick, living, and to the point! |
|
08-25-2012, 09:56 PM | #8 | |
Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Renton, Washington
Posts: 3,545
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
|
|
08-28-2012, 12:55 PM | #9 |
Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: DFW area
Posts: 4,384
|
Re: Organic Salvation
What I find interesting is that I am regularly reading in mainstream Christianity about the hollowness of WWJD. And like some of the posts here, they are not dismissing it, just putting it in its place.
The problem is that if you are talking about the source of salvation, it is by grace (and depending on where you are reading, with additional descriptors like "by faith"). But if you are talking about the ongoing salvation, it requires that we do. And we have been instructed in both the gospels and the epistles to follow and imitate. So there is an aspect of WW[w]D (what would [whoever] do). Not saying that we can follow just anyone. But we have been instructed to follow Christ, as well as follow those that you know are following Christ. "Organic" is a term that just gets me riled-up. But I will refrain from my typical comments and just say that I don't think that carbon molecules are very relevant to the discussion. "Organic," in this context, infers that that it is something that is actually changing about the person, not just behavior. And there is clearly truth in that. But the record in the scripture is that we also are never actually changed, but instead must apply ourselves to the task at hand. But note that I said "also" rather than "instead." The overall record is that we are being changed, but that we are never completely rid of the fallenness of our being. So we have something changing in us (you can call that organic if you like) yet we also have something of us that remains in its fallen state. There are no fully transformed people in this life. And so we use both what comes natural and what we must exercise our wills about to walk according to the way. And, like John said in one of his letters, if we think we have no sin, we are fooled. So we will fail. And we will continue to fail. And sometimes using our good minds to consider what someone else would do . . . or what we would not be ashamed for our mother to see . . . is part of how we make our way toward righteousness. It's a little like the old saying that if you don't plan to succeed, you have planned to fail. Yes, just thinking "WWJD" won't answer every question or decide what action to take in all cases. But at least having that frame of mind is necessary to any kind of move toward righteousness.
__________________
Mike I think . . . . I think I am . . . . therefore I am, I think — Edge OR . . . . You may be right, I may be crazy — Joel |
08-24-2012, 04:53 PM | #10 | |
I Have Finished My Course
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Avon, OH
Posts: 303
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
Peter
__________________
I Have Finished My Course |
|
08-24-2012, 08:58 AM | #11 | |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Natal Transvaal
Posts: 5,631
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
More and more, I am neither interested in imitating Jesus, nor being organically united with Him. Rather, I just see Him before me. I hear His voice. I sense His great love for His Father. There was a Man here on earth, who loved His Father and wanted to return home. Read Psalm 27. He was surrounded by death, but He never gave up hope that eventually He would be returned to the land of the living (v.13). To me, there is only one Man who could possibly fulfill Psalm 27. Not David, not Asaph or Heman, not you, not me, not Witness Lee nor Martin Luther. Only Jesus could walk those steps. When you see that, you are awestruck; you are still. Trying to follow Jesus is almost irrelevant. You are like Mary, sitting there before Him, going 'wow'. You are no longer Martha bustling about in the kitchen trying to do good. You are just blown away by the journey. The journey is a person. His name is Jesus. My return home to my Father is, yes, organically attuned to Jesus' return to His Father. It is just as real in me today as it was when the psalmist penned that 3,000 years ago. But organic union means nothing, nor does economy of God, or processed and consummated. The only thing that means anything is Jesus, and His love and obedience to His Father, and that He loved us and laid down His life for us. Now the door is open. We can return home to our Father. We were dead, but now we are alive and we are going home. ~Luke 15:24
__________________
"Freedom is free. It's slavery that's so horribly expensive" - Colonel Templeton, ret., of the 12th Scottish Highlanders, the 'Black Fusiliers' |
|
08-24-2012, 10:42 AM | #12 | |
Member
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 360
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
|
|
08-24-2012, 11:37 AM | #13 |
Member
Join Date: Aug 2012
Posts: 13
|
Re: Organic Salvation
What organic means to me is something that is allowed to grow naturally with minimal interference. Something that is given a good environment, suited for the type of organism it is. I like the word organic. To me it conveys more of the sense of allowing, rather than forcing. In psychology one organic school of thought, conceived of by Carl Rogers, utilizes person-centered therapy, which is also described as non-directive.
But I appreciate the WWJD thing as well. In psychology, an analogous school of thought would be behaviorism, the father of which was B.F. Skinner, which utilizes a very directive, prescriptive type of therapy. I only speak of psychology as that is my field, and I see many similarities to this field and religion: The fathers, the splitting offs, the now hundreds of theories and practices... Guess what? The single most important factor in therapy is the quality of the relationship between therapist and client, not the particular school of thought that the practitioner espouses.
__________________
Jesus wept. Last edited by coalsoffire; 08-24-2012 at 11:40 AM. Reason: Further enhancements added |
08-24-2012, 06:54 PM | #14 | |||
Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Natal Transvaal
Posts: 5,631
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
And speaking of not forcing, notice how Jesus never forced anyone. When they tried to recruit him to be king, He withdrew. When someone tried to get Him to tell someone else to give them some money, He replied, "Who made Me judge over you?" Contrast that with John the Baptist, who tried to tell King Herod not to consort with his brother's wife. The power Jesus was displaying with was on a whole different level. It was the power of peace. Quote:
Quote:
In the church life, we too often look at the external things. "Who is on first", i.e. who is in charge. We are too superficial, too surface-oriented. We miss the hidden things, the things which are real. Things like relationships. Mark 9:33,34 -- They came to Capernaum. When he was in the house, he asked them, "What were you arguing about on the road?" But they kept quiet because on the way they had argued about who was the greatest. The disciples had no idea what it meant to be "great". They were fallen creatures, separated from their Father in heaven. Jesus, however, knew that the Father was great, and never looked away; during His whole earthly sojourn, His relationship with the Father in heaven remained constant. So my question is: how can we look away from Jesus? Every time you look at Him, he is looking at the Father. If you have a relationship with Jesus, surely He will declare the Father to you. Just some thoughts from a pilgrim on the road.
__________________
"Freedom is free. It's slavery that's so horribly expensive" - Colonel Templeton, ret., of the 12th Scottish Highlanders, the 'Black Fusiliers' |
|||
08-24-2012, 08:45 PM | #15 | |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Greater Ohio
Posts: 13,693
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
__________________
Ohio's motto is: With God all things are possible!. Keeping all my posts short, quick, living, and to the point! |
|
08-24-2012, 01:31 PM | #16 | ||
Οὕτως γὰρ ἠγάπησεν ὁ θεὸς τὸν κόσμον For God So Loved The World
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 3,824
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
I’m going to pick on my dear brother Peter at this point. (Hey bro, you kind of asked for it with your usual invitation at the end… “thoughts?”.) Well these are my thoughts regarding such a term as “organic salvation”. I am not, repeat not, accusing you of, or even implying that you are “elevating this term to the level of scripture”. I’ve tasted enough of your spirit over the years to know that you would not do such a thing! However, you have made a pretty strong statement in testifying to us that “This teaching (organic salvation) is a cornerstone of my faith”. Them are some pretty serious words… “cornerstone of my faith”. I would submit that anything that is a cornerstone of one’s faith should surely be an essential item of such a faith. I’m not trying to put words in your mouth, but I am going to try to pin you down a bit. I would ask, can any extra-biblical word, term or phrase be considered an essential item of our faith? This is not a purely rhetorical question, and I think it’s a fair one. Quote:
Thoughts?
__________________
αὐτῷ ἡ δόξα καὶ τὸ κράτος εἰς τοὺς αἰῶνας τῶν αἰώνων ἀμήν - 1 Peter 5:11 |
||
08-24-2012, 04:06 PM | #17 | |
I Have Finished My Course
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Avon, OH
Posts: 303
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
This is a fair question. I should have made this clear in my post: It does NOT matter to me the specific phrase used. Actually, I agree with you (and Igzy that it would likely be better to utilize terminology directly from the Bible. What I appreciated about what I learned in the LC is not the "uniqueness" of the terminology. Rather, as I explained, it was a way of understanding the nature of salvation. You are right that salvation is a big, big word. It encapulated a LOT. I was trying to express that in my experience ESPECIALLY coming from the LC, there is a fundamental aspect to salvation that is important to continually be reminded of - specifically that God's salvation is through life and not form. The concept entails a lot of important things, often in ways that other teachings/practices (e.g. "WWJD") don't always. This "life relationship" or "organic salvation" entails a tremendous humility. Since it means that growth/progress cannot be formalized or turned into a formula, one must be humble and open to the Lord to work. It requires an interaction and a seeking. A questioning. There's a great quote from the poet Rilke which is something like "Do not now seek the answers, for even if you could obtain them, you wouldn't be able to live them out - and that is the point, to live everything. Rather, live the questions now and perhaps in some distant day you might live into the answer, without even knowing it." Because transformation isn't via edicts, it requires a constant petitioning of His will and His strength. One of the unintentional consequences of the WWJD type thinking is that it has a subtle hubris to it. On one hand, it seems straight-forward (e.g. turn the other cheek). Yet, in reality, we are master manipulators. Let's say we're talking to someone who we are unhappy with. What would Jesus Do? Well, if we convince ourselves this person is like the tax collector, we would be loving and receiving. However, if we convince ourselves that this person is a Pharisee, then we're justified in telling them off. We are so prone to want to "do Christianity right." But our tendency is to mechanize this, without the searching engagement God desires. Thus, seemingly well-intentioned people of faith who do everything "in His name" can actually fail to ever get to know Him (See Matthew 7: "I never knew you.") Well intentioned stalwarts of the faith can be convinced they know what God wants and inadvertantly attempt to keep Christ from being crucified all while trying to serve God. (See Peter and "get behind me Satan.") This "what is the Christian thing to do" which presumes you can actually derive an objective answer to life's messes has a touch of hubris, even if unintentional. That is why I so appreciate an emphasis on the unfolding nature and life relationship of salvation. Tryng to sum up this concept, "organic" seems an apt word - but the word itself is quite secondary. So - to be clear - it is SALVATION that is the 'cornerstone of my faith.' But it is this particular nature of it and how God accomplishes that is so encouraging and hope-filled to me. Thoughts? In Love, Peter
__________________
I Have Finished My Course |
|
08-24-2012, 06:51 PM | #18 |
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
Re: Organic Salvation
"Organic Salvation" is not simply a constructed term - it was coined to replace a genuine Biblical word and teaching that you surely hear outside the walls of the LC: "Sanctification" +- the process whereby, after Salvation, we are confromed to the image of the Son of God and made Holy, as He is Holy. In thought, word, and deed. It is a long process of growth - that does not end in this life, but is completed in the next. Surely you know this Peter?
|
08-24-2012, 09:50 PM | #19 | |
I Have Finished My Course
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Avon, OH
Posts: 303
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
That said, it was a "constructed" term. Indeed, what is the difference between "constructed" and "coined" - in your sentence "not simply a constructed term - it was coined..." These mean the same thing. I don't personally have an issue with taking a rich set of Biblical principles and using a single phrase to express them (the "trinity" is a good example of this). Which is why in my first post I didn't flinch at using the term as it wasn't an issue for me. But the term itself does not hold any particular import for me. It is the Biblical truths that are entailed in its definition that matter. Some here bristled at the "coining" of terms, because they believe that this can, sometimes, lead to a sentiment of being "special." I agree there can be this tendency. If someone is taking issue over a matter that isn't critical to the argument I'm making, I don't see a reason to fuss over it. That's all. In Love, Peter
__________________
I Have Finished My Course |
|
08-25-2012, 02:24 PM | #20 |
Member
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 360
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Neither do I. Organic salvation, trinity, incarnation, etc. can be useful to describe in brief larger subjects. But IMHO a legitimate complaint about Witness Lee and the Anaheim Politburo is they got lost in the language of theology in lieu of the reality.
|
08-24-2012, 10:05 PM | #21 | |
Οὕτως γὰρ ἠγάπησεν ὁ θεὸς τὸν κόσμον For God So Loved The World
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 3,824
|
Re: Organic Salvation
Quote:
As usual, Peter has gotten us into some deep quicksand here. Darn you, Peter, you got us into this mess....you are now responsible to get us all out!:rollingeyes2:
__________________
αὐτῷ ἡ δόξα καὶ τὸ κράτος εἰς τοὺς αἰῶνας τῶν αἰώνων ἀμήν - 1 Peter 5:11 |
|
|
|