[UntoHim]

Ok, this thread is being reopened.

I have asked NeitherFirstnorLast to continue on. I have promised him that any post that does not address what is actually quoted in the book will be deleted without warning. NFnL, being the thread starter will lead the discussions, and he will be given more leeway as far as exploring the topic at hand.

This is an important work. It deserves serious treatment. I will repeat what I said earlier, you don't have to agree with what Duddy has written, or for that matter what NFnL writes or anybody else, but I will INSIST that you address the matter at hand. Arguing for the sake of arguing and flaming other members will not be tolerated. NO EXCEPTIONS!

Let's give NFnL some time here to pick up the conversation. He can backtrack if he wants or simply go forward.