Quote:
Originally Posted by Disciple
Clearly this is not a direct quote from my post, to portray it as though it was is disingenuous. Then to say this is what I argued "straight up" is a lie.
|
Disciple,
My sense was that Peter was making a characterization of your argument. To me this is like if someone ran through a theater shouting "Flames! Smoke! Heat!" and Peter said that they ran through a theater shouting "Fire!" that person could say, "That is a lie. I never used the word, 'Fire' ". I felt he was characterizing your argument, even though he presented his characterization as quotes. And I felt his characterization was fairly accurate, though it might have been a bit too vehement (this from one whose posts are often too vehement, in retrospect).